Refinance or Trade In? Compare Total Cost, Not Just the Payment.
Both can lower your monthly payment. Refinancing keeps your car and replaces your loan. Trading in replaces the car, and often carries your old balance into a new loan. The cheaper option is the one with the lower total cost, not the lower payment.
Independent Reviews · No Credit Card Required · Know Your Options Before You Decide
How Refinancing and Trading In Compare
Refinancing can help if your credit has improved or rates are lower than when you bought. A longer term lowers the payment but can raise total interest. Trading in can help if the car itself is the problem, but if you're upside down, the shortfall usually moves to the new loan.
- You want a lower payment but like your car
- A dealer offered a trade-in deal with “zero down”
- Your credit score has gone up since you bought
- You're upside down on your current loan
- You're not sure how to compare the offers
Two offers with similar monthly payments can differ by thousands in total cost. Comparing the full numbers before you sign is the best protection.
An Independent Second Opinion Before You Decide.
- Your current loan: balance, rate, and remaining term
- Any refinance offer you've received
- Any trade-in offer and the new loan terms
- Your car's current market value
- A side-by-side comparison of total cost
- How much negative equity, if any, carries over
- Refundable add-ons that may reduce your balance
- Questions to ask lenders and dealers before signing
Always free. We don't arrange loans or sell cars, and we don't take commissions or referral fees.
We don't sell cars, loans, or warranties, and we don't take commissions from the companies you're questioning. CAS Verified is not a law firm or public adjuster.
Refinance or trade in car: Your Questions.
Is it better to refinance or trade in my car? ▼
Can I refinance if I'm upside down? ▼
Does refinancing hurt my credit? ▼
What happens to my GAP if I refinance? ▼
Does CAS Verified refer me to lenders? ▼
Comparing Offers? Get an Independent Second Opinion.
Send us your current loan and any offers. Auto loan reviews are always free.
Start My Free Review →Independent Reviews · No Credit Card Required · Know Your Options Before You Decide
Get Your Free Second Opinion.
Answer a few quick questions. A real person reviews your situation and replies within 1 business day, usually the same day.